Summary of Literature Review that I did for Public Health Agency of Canada on funding Collective ImpactA sounder understanding of scaling approaches, system change and the private sector ensures a more strategic approach to third-party vested partnership development. Salient in the literature is the importance of networking and networks that are shaping new roles for government, the community and the private sector. System change, in health and any sector, is about changes in behavior and services but also changes in confidence, attitudes and societal perspectives about the way we live, play, work and connect with one another.
There is an assumption that a strong project or model can be replicated for wider impact and reach in new populations and communities. However, the little evidence that we have about how social and system change works proves the contrary. These dynamics are home-grown, context-specific and highly based on relationships and motivations of the partners involved. Even the business models are relationship-based and embedded. The interventions were developed and adapted by those partners based on continual communication and shared analysis of emerging evidence.
PHAC-IS has already begun to ask questions about both organizational readiness and system-level readiness. Funders interested in system-level change that extends beyond service delivery, even integrated service-delivery, need to better understand how to assess system-level readiness. This type of analysis could include both the dynamism of the network as well as the extent to which partners share a vision, coordinate activities and share analysis in measuring change. Funding of strong backbone organizations or support across organizations is another consideration since evidence shows that one of the main reasons why networks and alliances fail is for lack of strong backbone support.
Understanding system readiness and system-level change will allow for more strategic analysis of where funding in its various forms including private sector capital can play a key role. A more nuanced understanding of the private sector hopefully opens up a much wider range of opportunities for the effective use of private capital in social and systems change for health equity.
Practically-speaking, this understanding means that partnership considerations with the private sector need to include a business/governance model that shows a sound understanding of the market and its opportunities as well as the range of private sector agencies and individuals that may be interested to play a role.
Partner interest and motivations are key as preliminary findings in the literature show that being champions, in-kind and other technical supports can be as, if not more important, than the financial capital. When and how the private sector comes in with its funding can also be important to ensure that it leverages rather than drives the ownership coming from the community and other partners.
In the consideration of third-party and private sector partnerships, it is important to think creatively in context about the range of private sector partners and the role of capital going beyond traditional understandings of philanthropy and private capital. Most of the interesting innovations are happening in the relatively new middle. These are partners who demand and, sometimes understand and expect both economic and social returns. These partners want to contribute in various forms.
Increasingly, and depending on the vested nature of these partnerships, they are demanding, not only good stories for corporate social responsibility. They are demanding evidence and adaptation as well as an ability to contribute to the analysis. Funding, both private capital and “smart subsidy,” can play a critical role in coordinating and consolidating these efforts to ensure that the full picture of healthy outcomes and impacts are being captured and realized.
| related link
I mean agency I mean
justice is not bred to
move in political realms
is it because the path is simply
one of snakes and ladders, spirals
because we don’t find the right
balance of love and power,
between growing trees and
navigating jungles or we chickegg
the poor thing into parts until
it’s dying or stuck and
we’ve failed to watch
how it moved. Is it
because we miss in it
the moral power, the
the trust, the critical
intangible of the
townhouse, the gathering,
the dialogue, this dialogue,
our kite and our stars.
This found poem was generated from a forum that I participated in at the Coady Institute on the links between economic and political citizenship. For me, as I describe in my bio, the two have always been tied though political (in the broadest sense) agency cannot be assumed.
Gorgeous kayaking trip with Oliver exploring the Eastern Shore Islands. Part of the protected areas. Great news this summer that Nova Scotia has dedicated 13% to wilderness protection. That places NS second behind BC. Here it is much more challenging where over 75% of land is privately owned. In BC, it is only about 15%.
Examples: Cross-cultural neighbourhood revitalization in San Diego, reclamation of land and heritage in the Deep South, green retrofitting in Buffalo, conservation-based enterprises in the West Coast, land trusts using permaculture in Tennessee, Inuit self-determination in the Arctic.
I was excited to be part of some of the early research and case-study identification. Inspiring stories of a new public and new economic models where community members are the drivers. There were examples of community investors, housing trusts, cooperatives, neighbourhood associations, a coastal loan fund. The key was starting small and local, building energy and trust. Passion capital someone called it. Also financial contributions from the community tied to ownership and decision-making. Then external support and finance was leveraged.
This is so possible in our neighbourhoods in Halifax, especially in the North End where we have passion capital to spare! Urban Roots Farm and Hope Blooms are some inspiring examples. The St. Patrick's Alexander school site is another opportunity.
Check out the site below for details of the cases featured.
| related link